Desperate Housewife
Whenever we are asked about our most memorable cases, this one comes to mind, because it had all the elements of a made-for-television drama.
We were contacted by a husband who had received a strange email from someone claiming to be a private investigator. The sender claimed to have evidence that the man’s wife was having an affair with one of their children’s schoolteachers. He named the teacher and gave enough details for the husband to take the claim seriously, saying he was passing it along because he thought it was something the husband would want to know.
The husband hired us to investigate. We began by conducting surveillance of his wife and of the teacher. However, after several weeks we had not seen any indication that the two were meeting. Still, our client continued to receive emails from the person claiming to be a P.I. A private investigator notifying an unsuspecting spouse about an affair did not sound right to us, because the standard practice in our industry is to protect case and client confidentiality at all costs. So we decided to investigate the sender as well.
Our investigator could not find any record of a private investigator by that name, or of the agency named in his email address. Shortly afterward, our client looked out a window and saw his wife behind their house, having a heated argument with a man he recognized as a neighbor from down the street. The neighbor was only vaguely familiar to our client, yet that day he got the impression that his wife knew the man quite well. When he asked her about it, she said they were merely friends. Our client gave us the neighbor’s name and address, and what we discovered next turned the case on its head: the neighbor was not who he claimed to be. He was living under a false name and a false persona.
In a professional profile our investigator found online, the man claimed to be a successful, Ivy League–educated financier, but everything else we found suggested quite the opposite. Records indicated that he was unemployed and had a criminal record. He also appeared to owe several months’ rent to his current landlord, and he was a defendant in an ongoing sexual assault and burglary case. Hearing this, and suspecting that the neighbor was somehow involved, our client asked us to contact the teacher to find out what exactly was going on.
Our investigator met with the teacher at a local coffeehouse and was shocked by what he learned. The teacher admitted that he had had a brief affair with our client’s wife, but said he had quickly ended it after he began receiving threatening emails from a private investigator warning him to stay away from her. Someone had also contacted his employer and reported that he was dating the married parent of one of his students, which caused him considerable trouble at work. When pressed, the teacher revealed the private investigator’s name, and sure enough, it was the same person who had been emailing our client. The teacher gave our investigator copies of the emails, as well as a police report he had just filed about the harassment. He said he was now living in fear, because even though he was no longer in contact with our client’s wife, the threatening emails would not stop.
Our investigator reported back to the client, who then had a talk with his wife. She confessed that the neighbor was someone she had “flirted” with in the past, but said things got out of control when he became obsessed with her, and she had to tell him they could no longer be friends. Suddenly, the pieces of the puzzle began to fall into place.
Based on our investigation, we believe the client’s wife had originally had an affair with the neighbor but broke it off when she started seeing the teacher. Angry, the neighbor likely began following her to find out why she no longer wanted to see him, and in doing so learned about the teacher. He then concocted a plan to pose as a private investigator and email the other two men in hopes of exposing the relationship, perhaps for revenge, or perhaps to break up the affair so he could have her back.
Several protective orders, lawsuits, and criminal charges were filed in connection with this matter, and our client pursued a divorce.
